Was Textile Armour More Effective at Stopping Arrows than Mail?



Did chainmail protect against arrows?

Conclusion: Good maille is very effective against arrows and is extremely difficult, if not impossible, to cut with a sword. However, it is no match for heavy polearms such as the poleaxe, and swords with very acute points can at the very least draw blood without much effort. A good thrust from such a sword can kill.

What are Gambesons made of?





Gambesons were produced with a sewing technique called quilting. They were usually constructed of linen or wool; the stuffing varied, and could be for example scrap cloth or horse hair. During the 14th century, illustrations usually show buttons or laces up the front.

Was chainmail actually effective?

Mail armour provided an effective defense against slashing blows by edged weapons and some forms of penetration by many thrusting and piercing weapons; in fact, a study conducted at the Royal Armouries at Leeds concluded that “it is almost impossible to penetrate using any conventional medieval weapon”.

What was chainmail weak to?

However, chainmail also suffered from a notable weakness in that sword and spear tips, or arrow heads, could penetrate individual ringlets at a direct-on angle. As such, knights would commonly wear a cuirass over the chainmail shirt for extra protection.

Is chainmail better than plate armor?

In terms of shock absorption, plate armor is far better than mail armor. The rings of chainmail aren’t able to properly distribute the impact energy of a weapon. For this reason, a longsword strike may already be enough to incapacitate a mail wearer, as the attack causes severe trauma and bone fractures.

Is scale mail better than chainmail?





Scale armour offers better and more solid protection from piercing and blunt attacks than mail. It is also cheaper to produce, but it is not as flexible and does not offer the same amount of coverage.

Can chainmail stop stabbing?

Although chain mail can stop a stab from a fat blade, a thin blade can push through some chain mail hauberks (mostly those of low quality). As a complete armor system (mail+gambeson), chain mail was fairly warm to wear. This caused problems for the Crusader armies and the 1066 Norwegian army that invaded England.

Can a spear break armor?

Both plate armour and mail will very effectively stop a spear. A couched lance can penetrate mail in a cavalry charge, but other than that they’re not very good weapons for causing damage through armour.

How effective is lamellar armor?

The leather lamellar proved to be particularly effective only when defending against bolts and arrows. The steel lamellar proved to be considerably effective against slashing, thrusting and piercing attacks but was comparatively weak against bludgeoning attacks.



Is chainmail armor flexible?


Quote from video: Похожие запросы

Would chainmail stop a bullet?

Chainmail , and even the kind of full armor that knights wore, is useless against firearms. Or, as they say, yes, chainmail will stop a bullet, as long as you don’t throw it too hard. Soft body armor, whether made from silk or paper, is actually more effective than metal armor.

Can arrows pierce plate armor?

Computer analysis by Warsaw University of Technology in 2017 demonstrated that heavy bodkin-point arrows could penetrate typical plate armour of the time at 225 metres (738 ft).

How long did it take to make a chainmail shirt?

If chainmail is produced in a workshop, many workers can team up and start with sheets of chainmail that they have prepared in advance. Thus it would take one or two weeks to build a custom-tailored chainmail shirt. I assume it was done this way in the middle ages. 3.



What is Bodkin arrow?

The bodkin arrowhead was a very simple head made from square steel stock that was flattened on one end and rolled into a hollow section that was attached to the arrow shaft. The other end was sharpened into a point. These arrowheads were used extensively in the middle ages.

Can crossbows penetrate armor?

Quote from video: I think you'd be fine same bolt with the heavy crossbow. And i don't think i have to take that many more shots against this armor. It's pretty obvious that it.

Can an arrow pierce metal?

Well, first of all a real longbow can penetrate steel armor, as long as the arrowhead is made of forged, hardened steel.

How far can an English longbow fire an arrow?

The bow was held with outstretched arm and the arrow drawn back to the bowman’s ear. An English archer could shoot six aimed shots a minute, and his effective range was about 200 yards, though an arrow could go twice as far in the right hands.

How far did medieval archers shoot?

long. A trained archer could shoot 12 arrows a minute, but some sources say that the most skilled archers could fire twice this number. The arrow could wound at 250 yards, kill at 100 yards and penetrate armor at 60 yards. At the battle of Agincourt in 1415, 1,000 arrows were fired every second.



What is the heaviest bow?

The heaviest production model compound bow had a draw weight of 100 pounds and was built by PSE. More commonly available bows max out at 80 pounds as rated by the manufacturers. However heavier weights may be available through custom order or custom fabrication.

What was the draw weight of a medieval longbow?

A six-foot bow made of yew wood, the English longbow had a draw weight of between 80 and 150 pounds, an effective range of up to 350 yards. The heavy war arrows used were able to penetrate all but the very best steel plate armor of the medieval period.

What made the longbow so effective in battle?

Longbows were serious weapons, and their power was immense. Arrows could penetrate chain mail with relative ease, and frequently did, making plate armour more and more necessary.

What was the most powerful medieval bow?

Immortalized by the Mongols during the 3rd-century onwards, the Mongolian recurve bow is widely considered one of the most powerful, and deadly, bows in history. These bows could famously shoot with pinpoint accuracy at over 500 yards (450+ meters), and were often used from horseback.



Why was the longbow better than the crossbow?

In fact, during field-battles the longbow had a clear advantage over its counterpart. Not only could a longbow fire further than a crossbow – at least until the latter half of the 14th century – but a longbowman’s average rate of fire was significantly greater than that of a crossbowman.

Were medieval crossbows more powerful?

Medieval crossbows, even those with hundreds of pounds of draw weight, only shot bolts at around 140 feet per second, which is not much faster than the longbows of the time. Their strength, as it is today, was their incredible potential for accuracy, which far surpassed that of longbows.

Is a crossbow more accurate than a bow?

The crossbow is heavy, cumbersome and awkward to handle in the stand compared to a vertical bow. The physics of the crossbow make it difficult to steady when shooting, which makes the crossbow less accurate than the vertical bow.

Why did guns replace bows?

Arrow makers or Fletchers were highly skilled professionals and supplying a large cohort of archers would be much more expensive, and time-consuming than producing a shot for early muskets. So there you go, mystery solved! Money and time seem to be the answer to why bows were replaced with guns.

Why did the English stop using longbows?

It was so important that in 1472 the king passed a law that every merchant ship that came to England must provide 4 bow staves for every ton of cargo. In the 16th century the handgun replaced the longbow. The first handguns were primitive but they gradually improved and by the 1580s the longbow was obsolete.



When did swords stop being common?

Around the 15hth century, swords began to decline in use. Because plated armor was so strong, swords couldn’t do any serious damage. In this period, maces became very popular, as they were heavy and most of them spikes that were effective against armor.

Why bow hunting is better than rifle?

“If you are talking about legally hunting an animal, a bow and arrow would be preferable to a gun if you believe in giving the animal a fair chance at survival. “Using a bow pits user hunting skills [against] animal instinct. Using a rifle at distance takes away the animal’s skill at survival…

Do deer feel pain when shot with an arrow?

Deer are mammals, so their nervous system resembles a human’s, Ross said. They likely have similar perceptions and reactions to ours, but the degree to which they feel pain is subjective, most researchers say.



Is bow hunting unethical?

In answer to the question, “Is Bowhunting Ethical?”, “Yes bow hunting is ethical“. It is governed by a set of written and unwritten laws of morality and humanity. There are those who choose not to follow the laws.

Why is bow hunting so hard?

For the average person, an ethical shot with a bow requires him to be within 50-60 yards of the animal — a remarkably difficult task with a wild animal on high-alert. On the other hand, most hunters with a decent rifle and magnified scope are more than comfortable at 300+ yards.

What is the easiest animal to hunt with a bow?

Easiest To Bowhunt



Most of the easiest animals are those that have an Achilles heel that favors bowhunters. For black bears, that would be their stomachs. Hunted over bait in the spring, they can be downright easy. For that reason they make the perfect beginner’s archery quarry.

Why do I always miss deer with my bow?

In addition to rushing the shot, the second most common reason that an archer will tend to miss while bow hunting is simply often a lack of fundamentals. This involves everything from not drawing fully to your anchor point to jumping the peep sight and not following through with your release.

What percent of hunters use a bow?

Bowhunting is an important aspect of life for many Americans. A 2016 survey funded by the U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service discovered the following facts. More than 11 million Americans hunt that represents about 4.5% of the total population. Thirty-two percent of the 11 million people hunt with a bow.

Is rifle or bow hunting harder?

Difficulty of rifle hunting



The bowhunters out there might cringe a little at this, but all hunting is difficult, including rifle hunting. While it isn’t as difficult as toting a bow, it does come with its own set of challenges.

What’s better bow and arrow or gun?

Firearms accumulate wear more slowly than compound bows, which is why used guns retain so much of their value. Compared to bows, guns have more recurring costs: bullets and shot. Shooting practice can get expensive if you want to visit the range frequently. By contrast, arrows can be used many, many times.

Similar Posts: